Saturday, September 10, 2011

DC Comics - The New 52 - Week 1...

If you're not aware, DC Comics have recently relaunched their entire line of books, and as someone who has never read any DC before, I thought this would be a good time to jump on-board. Once I started reading them, however, it occurred to me that I might lose track of which ones I do and don't like, so I've decided to do mini-reviews for each as I go.

I've rated each one I've read, given my quick thoughts, and a final verdict. "Subscribe" means I'm on for the ride, "Pull" means I'm not sold and will see how the next issue or two pan out, whereas "Drop" means I have no interest in reading any further issues.

Week 0
Justice League
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Someone described this book as feeling like a video game, so perhaps that's why I liked it so much.
Verdict: Subscribe
Week 1
Action Comics
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: The dialogue felt over-written and the events a little incoherent.
Verdict: Pull
Animal Man
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Started a little slow, but got better towards the end.
Verdict: Pull
Batgirl
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: I'd never had any interest in Batgirl before, but that's all changed now.
Verdict: Subscribe
Batwing
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Loved it! Very Moon Knight.
Verdict: Subscribe
Detective Comics
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Story felt a bit generic, but the hook has me.
Verdict: Pull
Green Arrow
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Nothing too exciting here.
Verdict: Drop
Hawk and Dove
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Nothing great.
Verdict: Drop
Justice League International
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Kind of boring.
Verdict: Drop
Men of War
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Good to see the DCU from another point of view.
Verdict: Pull
OMAC
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: I don't know why, but this felt like a very old-school story.
Verdict: Drop
Static Shock
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: The "teen speak" dialogue loses me every time.
Verdict: Drop
Stormwatch
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Too expositiony and slow.
Verdict: Drop
Swamp Thing
Writing:
Art:
Overall:
Thoughts: Creepy. Awesome. Brilliant.
Verdict: Subscribe

2 comments:

  1. Sorry you didn't like OMAC, I really enjoyed its fun, old-school flavor - definitely sticking with it.

    Really didn't enjoy MEN OF WAR though ... can't quite put my finger on why, just fell very flat.

    Also going to stick with Stormwatch because Paul Cornell usually comes good in the end. First issue wasn't great though, so can see why you'd drop it.

    Totally agree with you on Static Shock, such a shame too, the character has a lot of potential but it came across as another generic teem-hero tale, and I've read enough of those.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was so bummed about Green Arrow too... it was so bland... ugh.

    ReplyDelete